Home » Blog » Currently Reading:

Monopoly City Streets – A Hit New Board Game Or Will Players Be Bored?

September 11, 2009 Blog No Comments

monoply-city-streets-game-google-mapsI read a recent article on the PC World web site, “Monopoly City Streets’ Online Game: Will Buying Park Place Be Any Easier?” where Hasbro has taken Google Maps and combined it with their highly successful traditional board game Monopoly.  Here are some thoughts.

First off, this is a great idea!  Of course, Monopoly and Google Maps!  I’ll bet that one was thought up over a pint or two!

One of the Lon Safko quotes on my web sites says, “Innovation is taking two things that are ordinary and combining them in a way that makes them extraordinary”.  That’s kind of what I’ve done throughout my career.  Nothing truly new is ever invented.  This is just two items we all knew, combined in a unique way.  Still, very innovative!

Now, does it have staying power, stamina, substance of a true strategy board game or will the player get bored?  The reason that Charles B. Darrow of Germantown, Pennsylvania, 1934 original Monopoly game is still with us is structure and a very delicate balance of rules, surprise (random occurrences both good and bad), strategy, and the ability to comprehend the object and strategy of the game easily.

There are 10o’s of 1,000’s of board games that have been invented that no one has ever heard of.  The story line or theme might be fun, but it never achieves that delicate balance enough to make people want to play it more than once.  Heck, even I invented a board game 15 years ago call “The Search For The Lost Dutchman’s Gold”, based on a true legend of the richest gold mine ever here in Phoenix.  In 1992, I actually located the mine.  I thought the game was really cool, had all of the elements listed above, and based on 300 years of history, it was historically correct.  Here’s a link to my pdf book I wrote several years ago about it and other stories:  http://www.lonsafko.com/internet_downloads/Gratuitous_Serendipity.pdf

The problem was, the game lacked that delicate balance.  It didn’t keep my interest for more than one play.  The reason board games are successful and have stood the test of time is that balance.

Chess has been around for hundreds of years in one variation or another.  Chess lasts because even though the number of possible legal moves are estimated to be between 10^43 and 10^50 (this is a “10” followed by 50 zeros), there’s only 16 pieces allowed to make 20 initial moves.

Checkers has withstood the test of time because even though there are 500 billion billion (5 x 1020) possible situations in Checkers, there are only 64 squares with each player moving only 12 black or 12 white or red pieces.

Tic Tac Toe has only one “piece” per player “X” or an “O”  In Tic Tac Toe there are only possible series of moves (9 factorial: 9 x 8 x 7 x …  x 1).  ( know I stretched the definition of board game to accurate Tic Tac Toe, but it is a board game; a grid of 3 by 3 squares for a total of 9.

All of these games above, including Monopoly are called “Closed Mathematical” games.  There is a finite number of possible plays and solutions.google-maps-monopoly-city-streets-game

The reason Chess keeps you interest is because in the human mind it’s nearly open ended with that massive number of possible moves.  Chess keeps your interest because it’s easy to comprehend, and the play is never the same twice due to its large number of possible moves.

Checkers, while it is still a closed mathematical game, for all intent and purposes in the mind of the player is still open with its 500 billion billion possible moves.

With Tic Tac Toe, which is also closed mathematical game, its total number of possible moves are only 9.  Hence you get bored with the game after only a few plays.  (Also, there are only two spaces you get on the first move where you can win.  If you don’t get one of those two spaces on the first move, the game will always result in a tie or a loss.  This make the game unsuccessful.  Only very young children can tolerate the game.

So, back to Google Monopoly.  From what I’ve seen it’s too open ended; using any streets in the world.  There’s no “track” to follow around, no structure.  The random surprises have to be balanced, but I didn’t see that.  And really, the only difference between playing the tried and true version of the original Monopoly and Google Monopoly is instead of its recognizable square track and familiar street names, you play on a map.  A confusing, unfamiliar, random geometry map.

Lastly, on-line participation, collaboration, virtual play, trusted networks, and MMOG, (Massively Multiplayer Online role-playing Game) is going to have a great appeal.  With games such as Halo 3 and World of Warcraft exceeding 10 million registered players there should be a short term appeal for this game.  And, if the Monopoly “money” was tied to actual credit cards similar to other on-line gambling…  Now you have a winner I would invest in!

Comment on this Article:







Download Free Content

Enter your email below and I'll send you a password that will allow you access to all of my free content!

Get Access Now

Privacy Policy

RSS Subscribe

Subscribe

Add Lon To Google+

Review Lon’s Products

Bluehost Hosting

Book Accolades

"The social media phenomenon is still ramping up and this book provides useful and timely business advice."
Vint Cerf, Father Of The Internet

Vint Cerf

"Lon is a serial technologist who really understands social media and is also blessed with the gift of being a great communicator. His book deftly takes you from "Social Media 101" all the way to PhD status in a format that is easy to browse, informative and powerful."
Tom Asher
Director Consumer Relations North America
Levi Strauss & Co

“Lon Safko and The Social Media Bible address the key questions – Why should I take part in Social Media? How should I take part? How do I reap the greatest benefits? – while also providing the push to take the next step.”
Jeff Hagen
Director, Consumer Services
General MIlls

General Mills Logo

"Effectively harnessing the power of social media is a top priority in corporate America.  “The Social Media Bible” with its informative and tactical approach, provides an easy-to-follow roadmap for how to do social media right."
Todd Simon
Senior Vice President
Omaha Steaks

Omaha Steaks Logo

"Social Media and Customer Care are rapidly coming together. This Second Edition is a must read for any professional who wants to stay on top of this rapidly changing topic. From the basics to long term Social Media  strategy, this is the only resource book to have on your desk."
Scott Ross
Senior Vice President, Sales & Marketing
NCO Group

NCO Logo

What People Are Saying About Lon!

Visit Lon In Second Life

Book Lon

  • Lon’s Presentations


    Fairleigh Dickinson University
    Madison, New Jersey, MN
    1/31/12



    John Roberts Printing
    Minneapolis, MN
    1/31/12



    National NeedleArts Association
    Phoenix, AZ
    1/20/12



    International Book Tour
    Amsterdam & Arnhem, Netherlands
    12/4-10/11



    National Speakers Association
    Tempe, AZ
    11/12/11



    Chevron
    Austin, TX
    11/9&10/11




    Westchester College
    Valhalla, NY
    11/1/11




    SCORE Westchester
    White Plains, NY
    11/1/11



    SCORE
    Rochester, NY
    10/27/11




    Social Share Summit
    Rochester, NY
    10/26/11



    SCORE
    Pittsburgh, PA
    10/25/11




    Printing Industries of America
    Pittsburgh, PA
    10/24/11




    Arizona BioTech
    Phoenix, AZ
    10/14/11




    Franchise Social Media Summit
    Internet
    9/21/11




    Nevada State Bank Webinar
    Internet
    9/8/11




    WBON: Success Strategies
    Phoenix, AZ
    9/7/11




    SCORE.org "Every Question... Q&A"
    National Webinar
    9/1/11




    SCORE.org "TraDigital Media Marketing"
    National Webinar
    8/25/11




    SCORE.org "Top 20 Excuses"
    National Webinar
    8/18/11




    SCORE.org "Five Steps To Success"
    National Webinar
    8/11/11




    SCORE.org "The BIG Picture"
    Phoenix, AZ
    8/4/11




    Peoria Chamber Of Commerce
    Peoria, AZ
    8/3/11




    IQPC "Achieving Executive Support“
    Webinar
    8/1/11




    Outwitting the Social Media Devil
    Phoenix, AZ
    7/15/11




    Mesa Chamber of Commerce Luncheon
    Mesa, AZ
    7/12/11




    Peoria Chamber Of Commerce
    Peoria, AZ
    7/6/11




    IABC - Phoenix
    Phoenix, AZ
    6/16/11




    AZ Tech Council
    Phoenix, AZ
    6/15/11




    Social Pulse 2011
    Las Vegas, NV
    3/23-24/11




    Phx Business Journal
    Phoenix, FL
    3/10/11




    Save The Small Business Tour
    Jacksonville, FL
    2/17/11




    Save The Small Business Tour
    Orlando, FL
    2/16/11




    Save The Small Business Tour
    Tampa, FL
    2/15/11




    Save The Small Business Tour
    Miami, FL
    2/14/11




    Blaze Book Publishing
    San Diego, CA
    2/26/11




    Arizona Book Publishing Association
    Phoenix, AZ
    1/26/11




    Infusionsoft Revolution Tour
    Phoenix, AZ
    12/03/10




    Save The Small Business Tour
    Naples, FL
    11/10/10




    Save The Small Business Tour
    Las Vegas, NV
    09/09/10




    Save The Small Business
    Phoenix, AZ
    10/15/10




    International Growth Tour
    Phoenix, AZ
    08/12/10




    EDM Series - Denver, CO
    05/28/10




    EDM Series - Detroit, MI
    03/25/10




    EDM Series - Orange County, CA
    04/13/10




    EDM Series - Pasadena, CA
    04/14/10




    EDM Strategy - Phoenix, AZ
    02/11/10




    EDM Big Picture - Phoenix, AZ
    02/09/10




    EDM Strategy - San Diego, CA
    02/04/10


    <
    strong>
    EDM Big Picture - Tucson, AZ
    12/10/09



    EDM Big Picture - San Diego, CA
    12/01/09




    EDM Big Picture - Phoenix, AZ
    10/22/09

    BuzzRoll

    Amazon Book Reviews

    Amazon Logo
    Amazon 6 Stars
    This book is an 800-pound guerilla when it comes to social media marketing. Four thumbs up!

    By: Jeff Lippincott "www.Jlippin.com" (Princeton, NJ USA)

    Great book! Loved it! It's huge and heavy and not particularly pricey. I found it to be well organized and well written. And it was certainly packed to the gills with content. There are 43 chapters split into three different sections: (1) Background basics & tactics, (2) Tools, & (3) Strategy. The chapters in the first part provide an introduction and framework regarding the book. The numerous chapters in the second part cover 100+ social media tools. And the last five or six chapters in the third part can help you do an audit of the social media marketing your company does (or doesn't do).

    The book is comprehensive. I haven't seen a book that covers so much and in such depth on the topic of social media marketing (or Internet Marketing). There were a ton of "Expert Insights" sprinkled throughout the text that really made the book shine. And each chapter ended with three summaries: (1) Commandments, (2) Conclusion, & (3) Readings & Resources. Each were well done. In particular the Readings & Resources for each chapter were better than most books have at the end of an entire book. 6 stars!

    PS. To see the chapter titles and how the book is specifically organized I encourage you to peek at the Search Inside feature Amazon offers for this book. With 43 chapters there are a lot of chapter titles to read.

    Amazon 6 Stars
    A Comprehensive Social Media Resource

    By David J. Perdue "MINDSTORMS author" (St. Paul, MN)

    Ask a hundred people what "social media" is, and you may get a hundred different definitions. Frankly, social media doesn't just connect people--it baffles them, too. The authors of "The Social Media Bible," however, have made a considerable attempt at creating a resource that helps readers gain an overall understanding of the social media "ecosystem" (to put it in the authors' terms) and how the social media phenomenon relates to business.

    First, I think it's in order to discuss what this tome covers. Part I, Background Basics and Tactics, comprises the first 23 chapters. This section of the book defines social media, explains the different types of social media, and helps you understand why it's important. You get coverage here of everything from social networks to microblogging to virtual worlds. If you've read other books about social media, you may already be familiar with some of this content. If you're brand new to social media, you'll find it especially helpful.

    Part II, Tools, comprises chapters 24-38 and revisits the different categories of social media, focusing on current popular tools. The authors discuss each tool, focusing on who should use them and why; you'll even find some more technical information in these chapters. Although I appreciated the broad look at all the different types of the social media, I felt that the sections could have gone into more detail. However, you could easily write an entire book on each type of social media presented, so the authors clearly had to limit coverage of each type of social media resource.

    Part III, Strategy, includes the final chapters of 39-43 and offers some excellent advice on how to apply everything learned in the book. I appreciated the bits of advice spread throughout as well as the cohesive strategies presented. I especially found the chapter "The Four Pillars of Social Media Strategy" helpful, which discusses how a social media strategy should have goals of communication, collaboration, education, and entertainment.

    Although some of the principles in this book will endure, much of the descriptions for current social media tools will quickly go out of date (as some already have). However, the author clearly recognized this and intended it to be a timely book. If you're new to the concept of social media and seeking how to apply social media to your business, the "Social Media Bible" is a great resource. If you're already familiar with using social media, you may find yourself skipping some of the basic information in the book. Overall, I believe there is wisdom for everyone to find in this useful guide--the kind of wisdom that will help you to give new life to your company's online marketing efforts in the social media world.

    Amazon 6 Stars
    From A to Z- it's all here!

    By Mark Amtower "Mark Amtower, consultant, autho... (Highland, MD)

    Lon Safko's 2nd edition of The Social Media Bible literally covers everything from A (apps) to Z (Zooomr) and everything in between. This is the most comprehensive book on social media available! If you currently use or plan to use social media in ANY form, I suggest you add this to your library TODAY!

    Amazon 6 Stars
    Good resource for business leaders wanting a greater understanding of social media

    By Chris Ray

    Rapidly advancing technology has produced new ways for individuals, groups, and businesses to communicate, collaborate, and market their products to consumers. Social media is leading the way in improving how business is conducted but many businesses and individuals are nervous about when and how to enter this new wave. In The Social Media Bible the author indicates the book is a comprehensive guide on social media intended to help readers increase revenues, profits, and competiveness in the marketplace. The book is divided into three main sections; part one, the background and basics of social media; part two, the plethora of social media tools available; and part three, developing a social media strategy. Within each of these sections the author provides the reader with the overall footprint of social media: its uses, platforms, and strategies currently employed by various companies. The book is well organized with each chapter providing definitions, examples of successful strategies, and multiple references that afford the reader a helpful guide should they continue their own research on the specific topic.

    Clearly the freshness of the content of any book on social media is limited given the rapid pace of technological innovation in the social media universe. However, for the reader who needs a starting point for discovering the basics of utilizing social media strategically, The Social Media Bible is an excellent resource from which to begin. Furthermore, the author effectively communicates the necessity for business leaders to get in the social media race or risk becoming extinct. This is true for both businesses and the individual business worker. Social media holds promise for improving both the internal and external communication strategies of companies. The book outlines both how social media can improve productivity as well as penetrate new and existing markets more effectively. The chapters on the various social media tools available provide the reader an extensive list of platforms to research, explore, and choose from when considering how one medium might be a more effective choice depending on the reader's particular business environment.

    The author could have improved the book by shortening the history and background section that contained too much basic information. In addition, for readers already active in utilizing social media tools in business it is doubtful they will discover any earth shattering new information in The Social Media Bible. However, for those just beginning to consider social media as part of their business strategy, the author does provide sufficient information readers will find helpful. Certainly there are companies and organizations that have yet to utilize social media as part of their overall business strategy. Readers who find themselves working for those companies will find the book to be effective in giving them an adequate knowledge base in social media that could be useful in educating their organizational leaders on the potential benefits of including social media in their business model. The book may also inspire some readers to launch new initiatives at their workplace or even to become entrepreneurs themselves.

    Amazon 6 Stars
    Book & Purchase experience review

    By R. Freeman (Sharon, MA United States)

    Great book. Really covers Social Media and related online marketing concepts (like SEO). Worth the price. And, the buying process was efficient, easy and painless. I would buy this all over again in a minute.

    Amazon 6 Stars
    Highly recommended for any business collection

    By Midwest Book Review (Oregon, WI USA)

    The second updated edition of The Social Media Bible has been revised and updated with user feedback and content, and offers the latest techniques, platforms and technologies for understanding and effectively using social media marketing. Interviews with 50 experts accompany keys to winning in social media efforts in this fine survey, highly recommended for any business collection.

    Amazon 6 Stars
    If you need to know about Social Media - OWN THIS BOOK TODAY - Six Stars !!!!

    By Richard Stoyeck "StocksAtBottom.com" (Westport, CT)

    The BOTTOM LINE If you must know about social media (SM), this is the only book to get on the market RIGHT NOW. First of all it was copyrighted in September 2010. This material changes quickly and new books are being printed all the time. At this time this is the most current and best book on the market. If it involves the Internet, you do not want to order anything that is more than one year old. So my first tip is always look at the copyright date. Older than a year, it's no thank you.

    The second tip is that you want something that you do not need to read from cover to cover, so the table of contents and the index is very important. The author went to a 1000 people involved with the Internet and asked them what do you need from a social media book. More than 66% couldn't define social media, while 99% recognized that SM would have a direct impact on their firm's bottom line. Based on their input, the author selected and developed the chapters, and the content.

    ORGANIZATION of the BOOK
    The 723 page SM Bible is divided intelligently into 3 parts.

    Part I TACTICS This runs from page 3 to page 447 and is contained in 15 chapters. This is where you will find out about podcasting, vlogs, blogs, followers, SEO, life casting, and flaming among others.

    Part II TOOLS of the TRADE This section runs from pge 447 to page 675. Here you will find the results of 100 companies that the author interviewed including marketing providers, game platforms, and the software you will need, plus the apps, websites, text messaging, mobile insights, and e-mail.

    Part III STRATEGY Here we have the Five Steps to Social Media Success. Each step gets a chapter, they are:


    * Analyze your existing media
    * The Social Media Trinity
    * Integrate Strategies
    * Resources
    * Implement and Measure

    CONCLUSION:
    If you need to learn more about social media, if you need to employ it for your business on whatever level, this is the book for you until the next new thing comes along. You have to be current, and stay current, and that means you do not want an old book. If you are a one person company or you have a thousand people in the company, at the moment there is no better source of information than this book. I heartily recommend it and thank you for reading this review.

    Richard C. Stoyeck